Would you track your projects in a spreadsheet? Your epics, your tasks, your team discussions, your progress?
Most likely not. We use tools like Jira, Trello, or Monday because they provide us with many answers out of the box. 1-click to know what's in progress, another to see a burn down chart, one more to change the status. You could do the same with Google Sheet and a few handcrafted formulas, but it's much easier and faster to get a good project management tool off the shelf.
The same applies to OKRs. We're in the early days of instrumenting strategy, and most teams still use spreadsheets to manage their quarterly goals. But, this comes at a cost. Just like with projects, there are some key questions that you should be able to answer quickly anytime during the quarter.
The answer to this question is not as easy as it looks. In fact, many teams today might be getting false positives due to the templates they're using. Let me explain.
OKRs are often presented as a table that only retains the latest progress update for each Key Result. It would be similar to looking at the chart below: you can see a data point, and you're good as long as you're above the progress line.
The issue here is that trends might tell us a different story. A week-by-week progress chart might not look so good.
If you want to do OKRs right, you should strive to have the same kind of visibility for progress on your Key Results. Don't settle for a single data point – make sure you can see trends instead.
You can do that by adding a column for each passing week in your template and then having a progress chart for each of your KRs. But you can start to see the complexity increasing, and there are other questions to answer.
This is a follow-on from the previous point. It needs to be easy for you to identify the OKRs that are in trouble in your organization. That's all the more important if you are a manager with several teams to look after.
With spreadsheets you'll need to craft custom filters to build your own dashboard, or wait on someone else to write you a report. Worse, you might not even have a way to get that info and will have to go through each sheet and comb the OKRs to identify the troubled ones.
Wouldn't it be best to have a simple way to isolate OKRs that require your attention?
OKRs are ultimately about collaboration. If all you do is looking at the progress of metrics, then you have a KPI dashboard – it's a great tool but it serves a different purpose. OKRs are about 2 things:
We often talk about the first benefit, but the second one is just as important. Progress on OKRs should be talked about every week, and it should help you have a healthy feedback cycle between the outputs produced by the team and the outcomes observed as a result.
Going back to spreadsheets, it's going to be almost impossible for you to keep track of weekly discussions and decisions. Knowledge will be lost, action items forgotten.