The credit union has 128,000 members, $2.1 billion in assets and 16 branches across six counties. It was chartered in 1954 for utility workers and opened to the whole community in 2009, but the name and look still suggest a closed employee group. Unaided awareness among local adults is 9%, against 34% for the largest regional bank, and 41% of people who have heard of us believe they cannot join. Members who do join stay: the net promoter score is 61. But the average member is 51, only 38% use us as their main financial institution, and three different logos are in use.
Challenges- Most local adults either do not know the credit union or assume it is closed to them, so rate advertising reaches people who think they are not eligible.
- Membership is aging. Adults under 35 are 31% of the local population but 17% of members, and 26% of members arrived through a car dealer loan and hold nothing else.
- The service members praise is not what the brand shows. Advertising leads with rates that national online banks beat, and each branch and department produces its own materials.
We will focus on- Households aged 25 to 40 in the six counties who are deciding where to keep a paycheck, a first car loan and a first mortgage.
- One idea, local decisions by people you can reach, proven by service standards we publish and meet.
- Consistency before reach: fix the identity and the employee experience in year one, then raise paid media in year two.
We will not- Changing the name. Research showed a new name would fix the eligibility problem faster, but signage, cards and legal work would cost about $1.8 million and put 70 years of local recognition at risk. We keep the name and add a line saying who can join.
- Rate-led advertising. We will not chase the savings promotions of online banks, even though rate offers bring deposits quickly.
- Renewing the regional sports arena sponsorship. The $400,000 a year moves to 40 smaller local sponsorships where staff turn up in person.